Some might wish it were bigger, for a roomier living area and maybe even room for two. While the fly is generously sized, the inner tent is more modest, at 30″ x 90″ x 43″ (W x L x H). Versus all of these shelters, the HR1 is also more storm-worthy and more modular, in the sense that its fly and inner tent are designed to be used together or independently, perhaps in conjunction with other components, e.g. The REI Quarter Dome is more similar in weight (it’s 2 oz less), but the HR1 still has 25 percent more protected square footage. For example, compared to the Big Agnes Fly Creek HV UL1, MSR Carbon Reflex 1, and Nemo Blaze 1P, the HR1 has up to 50 percent more protected square footage, uses fabrics that are up to 2x as waterproof, and costs $50 to $100 less. Any lighter solo tent entails major sacrifices. you can buy its products at REI), the High Route Tent is unique. If you decide to support another brand besides Sierra Designs, MLD would be a good choice.) Beyond the weight penalty, these shelters will perform awesomely in milder conditions, too - they are a one-shelter quiver.Īmong conventional manufacturers (i.e. (BTW, I have been a longtime user of MLD shelters. Here, the HR1 is more competitive: it is still 6 oz heavier, but it offers more usable space, better ventilation, taped seams, and $125 cost savings. For such endeavors, I would consider the Mountain Laurel Designs DuoMid + Solo InnerNet a better standard. Frankly, if I were doing a long-distance trip with relatively benign conditions like those encountered on the Pacific Crest or Continental Divide Trails (i.e., few storms, low humidity, bug-free nights, and dry campsites), I would find the potential weight-savings very attractive.īut (you know there’d be a “but,” right?) the HR1 was designed for nastier conditions: extended rain, strong winds, intense bugs, heat and high humidity, and moderate snowfall. As extremes, imagine replicating the Alaska-Yukon Expedition, partaking in the TGO Challenge, or thru-hiking the Wind River High Route. ![]() Not a featherweightĪt 22 ounces for the fly and 14 ounces for the inner tent (2 lbs 4 oz total, or 1020 grams), the High Route Tent FL1 (HR1) is notably heavier than one-person ultralight shelters like the ZPacks Hexamid Solo or a Mountain Laurel Designs Cuben Grace Tarp + Superlight Bivy, which both spec at less than 16 ounces (450 grams). What are you willing to sacrifice to save weight? Space, storm resistance, condensation management, modularity, price? The ZPacks Hexamid weighs half as much as the High Route Tent.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |